Skip to Content

10 Creative Mayo Flavors to Try on Your Next Sandwich

These ten flavored mayo recipes will transform your sandwiches, burgers, and appetizers into gourmet delights. Whether you’re craving something spicy, tangy, or full of fresh herbs, these easy-to-make mayo recipes will elevate any dish.

Curry Mayo

Curry mayo in a small jar.
Image Credit: Tastes of Homemade

Curry mayo, or curry aioli, is a creamy, slightly spicy dip or spread that is delicious on burgers or sandwiches or as a dip for sweet potato fries and other appetizers. Made with mayonnaise flavored with curry powder, garlic, and lemon and slightly sweetened with honey. The cumin, turmeric, and chili in the curry powder give this creamy mayo a warm flavour that goes well with so many things.

Get the Recipe: Curry Mayo

Jalapeno Mayo

Jalapeno mayonnaise in a small bowl.
Image Credit: Tastes of Homemade

Jalapeno mayo is a delicious condiment with the fresh flavour of jalapeno, cilantro and lime. This spicy mayonnaise works great as a dip, sauce or spread. It can be used to flavour sandwiches or burgers, as a dip for your favourite appetizers, or as a sauce for grilled chicken. The fresh jalapenos add spice balanced by the fresh herbs and lime.

Get the Recipe: Jalapeno Mayo

Garlic Chive Mayo

Mayonnaise with chives in a small jar.
Image Credit: Tastes of Homemade

This easy garlic chive mayonnaise is a creamy spread or dip that can be added to your favorite sandwich or served with a plate of appetizers.  This condiment is packed with flavor. It is made with store-bought mayonnaise, fresh garlic, and chives.  It comes together in five minutes and is delicious on chicken burgers or as a dip for french fries. 

Get the Recipe: Garlic Chive Mayo

Honey Mustard Mayo

Honey mustard mayonnaise in a small dish with a spoon.
Image Credit: Tastes of Homemade

A creamy, tangy mayo with a hint of sweetness. Honey mustard mayo is a simple condiment that mixes mayonnaise, mustard and honey. This mayo is fantastic spread on a sandwich or burger but is also delicious when used as a dip or sauce for your favourite appetizers. This mayo will become a staple in your refrigerator, made with only four ingredients and taking minutes to prepare.

Get the Recipe: Honey Mustard Mayo

Horseradish Mayo

Horseradish mayo in a small glass dish with a spoon.
Image Credit: Tastes of Homemade

A creamy blend of mayonnaise and horseradish, this easy horseradish mayo is a flavorful spread or dip. Use it to add flavor to hot roast beef sandwiches or as a creamy aioli dip for veggies, appetizers or french fries. Made with simple ingredients and ready in just 5 minutes.

Get the Recipe: Horseradish Mayo

Lemon Dill Mayo

Lemon dill sauce in a small jar with a spoon.
Image Credit: Tastes of Homemade

Lemon dill mayo is a creamy dip, spread, or sauce that can flavor your favorite appetizers or sandwiches. Made with store-bought mayonnaise, fresh dill and lemon, this creamy dill sauce comes together in minutes and is delicious with seafood, chicken, or vegetables.  

Get the Recipe: Lemon Dill Mayo

Burger Sauce

Burger sauce in a small mason jar.
Image Credit: Tastes of Homemade

This easy burger sauce is a delicious condiment that is a bit tangy, slightly sweet and full of flavour. It combines the most common burger condiments into one tasty sauce. Mayonnaise forms the base, which is blended with relish, ketchup, mustard, and seasonings. It is perfect for dressing a grilled hamburger but works as a sandwich spread, or you can use it as a dip for your french fries or favourite appetizer.

Get the Recipe: Burger Sauce

Spicy Sriracha Mayo

Spicy mayo in a mason jar.
Image Credit: Tastes of Homemade

A spicy sriracha mayo sauce that is slightly tangy with just the right amount of heat. This mayo is perfect for dipping your favourite appetizers or as a sauce for burgers, sandwiches or sushi.

Get the Recipe: Spicy Sriracha Mayo

Cilantro Mayo

Cilantro Mayonnaise in a small jar.
Image Credit: Tastes of Homemade

Cilantro mayo is a delicious condiment with the fresh flavors of cilantro and lime. This savory mayonnaise works great as a dip, sauce or spread. It can be used to flavour sandwiches or burgers, as a dip for your favourite appetizers or chicken wings, or as a sauce for grilled chicken or beef.

Get the Recipe: Cilantro Mayo

Peri-Peri Mayo

Spicy mayo in a small bowl.
Image Credit: Tastes of Homemade

Peri-Peri mayo is a spicy condiment made with creamy mayonnaise, Nando’s peri-peri sauce, a few spices, and fresh lemons.  This spicy mayonnaise works great as a dip, sauce or spread. Use it to flavour sandwiches or burgers, as a dip for your favourite appetizers, or as a sauce for grilled chicken or shrimp. 

Get the Recipe: Peri Peri Mayo

Sharing is caring!

THIS POST MAY CONTAIN AFFILIATE LINKS. AS AN AMAZON ASSOCIATE I EARN FROM QUALIFYING PURCHASES.